IFATCA's Spotlight Podcast
In our new podcast, IFATCA Spotlight, we shine a light on IFATCA's Member Associations. A podcast made by ATCOs for ATCOs to provide insight into different challenges and solutions found around the world.
IFATCA's Spotlight Podcast
Spotlight Episode 27 - Entry Point North
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In this new episode of the IFATCA Spotlight podcast, Entry Point North managing director Anne-Kathrine Jensen joins our host Thorsten Raue. They reflect on the organization’s 20-year journey from a Scandinavian air traffic control training startup to a global provider. Anne-Kathrine sketches how the company started, its expansion, its move toward AI-supported and competency-based training, and why objective assessment and student confidence matter for aviation safety.
Entry Point North is one of IFATCA's valued Industry Partners.
West S three four turn right setting up one three zero. Coming today to radar contact five level 370 and grow passing level. Welcome to a podcast IFATCA Spotlight where we normally shine a light on a member association, but this time we've got another industry partner sharing its insights and expertise that they bring to the IFATCA family. My name is Torsten, I'm from Germany, and in this episode is my pleasure to shine a light on Entry Point North, which is being represented by Anne Katrine Jensen. Welcome.
SPEAKER_01Thank you very much, Torsten. I've been looking forward to doing this podcast with you.
SPEAKER_00Awesome. We met in Bukarest in the Ifatka Annual Conference. You were taking part, for example, in the panel discussion, and I distinctly remember one sentence you said that I really loved. It was safety is not a department. I really like that approach. Like you can't just say it's safe because we've got a department. And um later on we talked and we got into the anniversary of Entry Point North. 20 years, and we decided to talk about 20 years of etco education. But before we go into that, give us a little bit of your background, Annekatrine.
SPEAKER_01My background is uh I was an air traffic controller in the ACC in uh Denmark, in uh Copenhagen. I worked there for quite some years, and then I got really interested in training. So I worked as set up training some years uh in Navia. And at the same time I was lucky enough to be sponsored by Navia to take an executive MBA. And at the same time I was part of a project where the three Scandinavian countries, Denmark, Norway, and Sweden, they looked into if they somehow could pool all their uh training needs together and have it delivered from one company. And this was super exciting, and I was thrilled to be part of the uh project. And it happened that when I finalized my MBA, they were looking for a managing director, uh and I applied and and got the privilege to start up this organization called Entry Point North. And it's true, it's 20 years ago, time flies.
SPEAKER_00Yes, it does. And you're still there, you're still thriving, perfect. So uh let's get into it. How did you start Entry Point North? Um, how did that little seed grow?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it has been quite an adventure and and really, really interesting in different phases depending on what we were doing. Because you can imagine as a start it was only me being employed, and then I got a promise from the three owners saying that look, we promise we will buy from you the first three years. We will pay you uh upfront in advance before the training courses, but after three years, you need to compete on the market. And that was a super challenging task. You can understand, of course, the first thing I thought about okay, I need to have some colleagues here who can help me build this whole thing. So I started uh defining okay, what type of roles did we need? Uh we started to uh find out where were we going to be, and we rented facilities from the Swedish ANSP LFV in the beginning. And then it was really all about rolling up our sleeves and preparing all the training material. I remember I I think I started in October, November, something like that, and already in March we had the first students coming in. So in that relative short time frame, we needed to employ a lot of people and we needed to develop the training materials as well, preparing for the students to arrive. So it was a super fun period where everybody did everything and we simply just helped each other with everything. You know, nobody was really there to uh clean or to uh yeah do the manual labor work. So we just did that together, all of us. It's super fun. Really a startup adventure, I would say.
SPEAKER_00Cool starting times when everything's still in flow and everybody does everything. But let me ask a question. Three countries got together, and so the first question always is, okay, then where do we put it? And next question probably is which language do you speak? Or do does entry point north at that point speak? So where is your headquarter? And what with which language did you start?
SPEAKER_01No, we started with the English language because we said even though Denmark and Norway and Sweden we pretty much understand each other, but since English is the official uh language within aviation, we thought, okay, we will stick to English. So all our documentation is in English uh from the very start, and and that has been super good since we had developed into this very global company. So it was a good thing. And somehow the owners agreed, and I don't know exactly how they did it, but they agreed that the headquarters should be in Sweden. So we are very close to Melmour, which is a city in the southern part of Sweden, quite close to Copenhagen, where I live. So I commute across uh the bridge every day from Copenhagen to Malmur.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's something quite a few people around the world can't get their head around. That you can just commute between countries, and it's so easy nowadays. That's really cool. I love that about Europe, the modern Europe. Um so you started in Malmu. Where did you start exactly?
SPEAKER_01The first I would say 15 years we were close to uh Stup Airport, and that's a little bit out in the countryside in Sweden. And the last five years we have been more downtown uh Malmu City Center, which is really, really good for the students and for the staff and so on. So we were quite happy when we got to move. And it was also a shorter driving distance from the majority of the people working here, so it was really nice.
SPEAKER_00Okay, thank you. You mentioned so you've got different phases in your development of entry point north. So we are in the start phase now, everybody's doing everything and you're building it up from ground. And let's say you said after three years there was this first point maybe where you had to compete. Was that one of the interesting turning points?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I would say so. You know, when we started, there was no harmonization in regulation. So since we had students from three different countries, we actually needed to have approval from three different regulators, which was kind of a burden because we wanted to have these students going together and and being uh around each other and and have them in in the same classes, you could say. And that was a little bit hard since we did not have only one set of regulation from one country that we had to live up to that came much later. So in the beginning, we it was a little bit burdensome with the with the regulation. And then you're quite correct, you know, in 2008 we had the financial downturn, and that meant that suddenly our three owners did not need as many air traffic controllers as they had expected they needed. And that was when we realized first time that wow, being a commercial company being dependent on only three customers and a limited amount of services, that's not a sustainable business model. That makes you very, very vulnerable. So we got our heads around this and decided that we need to be attractive to the global market. We we really need to have more services and we need to be able to attract more customers. So when we realized that, we made up a strategy on how to achieve that. And one of the first things we said was, okay, being a global company, what does that take? And in our opinion, it takes a global workforce. And uh so we have deliberately recruited people from many, many different places in the world. And today I think we have more than 20 nationalities together in the EPN group that we have evolved into. So I would say 2008 to 2010 was a huge um turning point in the way we saw ourselves and what kind of company we should be.
SPEAKER_00So you started with the Scandinavian countries basically, and then where did you extend to first?
SPEAKER_01I think that I think one of our first customers was a small uh airport from Switzerland, actually buying some services from us. And then we gradually, I can't really remember the order of when we or which customer came first, but we managed actually to attract quite a number of external customers outside our our our owners, and we we simply had to be more and more experienced in doing so. So it also meant that we we needed to establish ourselves more with the sales department because that was not something that we had been very focused on previously when we just did deliver services to the owners. And gradually, you know, we had to dig into marketing and you know, so we had to broaden our competences in the company quite a lot. And that was also super interesting because it was it was a quite different task compared to the first task that we we got when we started the company.
SPEAKER_00Right. So that's the next phase then growing from a kind of local company to a global company, and as you said, becoming an actual company that has to sell their product. Speaking about product, so of course, since it's an IFATCA podcast, we're talking mostly about EDCOs, but what do you sell? What's the product apart from EDCO education?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you're right. EDCO services are are very big for us, like initial training, transitional training, and even pre-OJT we also do for some customers. But besides from that, training for ADCEP is also becoming an increasingly big service for us because the systems, the ATM systems, get more and more advanced. And I think the role of the ADCEPs is becoming increasingly important. Who knows if they will be certified one day as well, like the air traffic controllers? I would expect so. So that's also a big and very interesting, you could say, service that we have delivered also globally. And then we have all kinds of related services like AFIS. Uh recently, a lot of airport services has come in. We do consultancies. Right now, you know, we are helping ANSPs being ready for the new regulation on compensate competency-based training and assessment, which comes into force in 29, where every unit has to change their unit training plan so that they can work in accordance with new regulations. And this is a very big task for any unit to transform into being compliant to this regulation. So it's a very, very broad palette we have today. I I would say that we are a one-stop shop for any operational need that an ANSP has.
SPEAKER_00Really good. I definitely want to go back to CBTA because that's uh, as you said, in Europe a huge um topic. But that would be now and the future already. So we've got to go back a little again. What would you say would have been the next phase? So you've grown into more of a global company with a diverse workforce, maybe challenges coming with that. What would be the next step you'd say?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. First of all, I like to address the thing you're mentioning about having it to be a challenge to having a very diverse workforce. I really don't see that that way. Of course, me being a Dane, it's very easy for me to work with people coming from the same cultural background as myself. However, it's also very boring because I totally understand where they come from. So it's so much more interesting for me and for for the other people working here, we agree on that, that we kind of get challenged by why are you thinking like that? That's that's really interesting. It's new to me. Can you explain a little bit more about this? And I think by having these diverse opinions coming in, we can make much better decisions where we have a much broader view on different things. So that's what I like the most about working in Libyan is really to be able to work in a truly global or with a truly global workforce. But you're true, it was a turning point, you know, after we became more global and we had much more customers. Then the next step was that we realized that maybe not every customer wants to send their students to Sweden. You know, some customers say, Why? Why wouldn't they? Yeah, why why wouldn't they? It's uh the beers are expensive, the weather is lousy, and it's far away from their home. Many NSPs they feel that training is very close to their heart, and they like to be somehow involved. And then we came up with the idea that okay, we might be able to take our knowledge about training, our uh know-how about simulators, about uh simulator exercises, you know, training concepts. Um we could take our quality compliance and assurance with us, package all that, and then together with partners in other countries, we could make giant ventures with them, and then we could carry out the training in their country. And we have done that several places in Europe, so we have now nine different training sites covering Europe. And if I can if I can just jump to now, then this week we are actually being audited in Bangkok, Thailand, where we will have our next training site opening in November. So so this is also it it was also a new concept that we started back in 2011. And it was uh Hungar Control in Hungary, who was the first brave joint venture partner of EPN, and we still enjoy working with Hungarocontrol. We have uh the joint venture EntryPoint Central together with them working also today. So it's a very good model.
SPEAKER_00Really good. So you successfully moved into the global market as definitely Bangkok is global. Congrats to that. By the way, you when you talked about uh diversity and not the only the challenges but the benefits it brings, you reminded me extremely of Helena, our IFATK president.
SPEAKER_02She's Lila, okay, yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_00It's perfect. I love it.
SPEAKER_02Okay, great, great.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Because we tended to go into the now already, let's let's talk about the last phase, moving into now and what the future holds. Um because we touched it already. So what would you say would would have been the last steps that have bring us to today?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I guess we can't do this podcast without just mentioning the horrible period with the COVID, because uh that was a phase that you know it affected aviation enormously, and it also affected us quite much because first of all, it was a difficult period financially because many of our customers they kind of had to save money, and sometimes saving on training is a is a is a quick fix. However, it hurts very much in the long run afterwards, but some customers did decide to close down their training activities. Other customers wanted to continue, and what we needed to do during the COVID periods was that we needed to find ways to deliver training in a digital format because people could not travel, they could not be together as they were used to, and we had to make some kind of um emergency solution where we managed to to deliver the training digital as best as we could. That made that kept us floating and it it kept actually the ANSPs to continue to do the training to some extent, meaning that they could continue their operation as well. So I think we all try to do as as the best we could, but I'm also very happy that this period is over, I guess everyone is. But of course, there's always something good coming out of a crisis, and one of the things that we wanted to do was uh to dig more into the digitalization, into the online training delivery, and to see how we can explore that more, how can we do a proper online training that that it is interesting to follow and that is something, you know, not like in the old days where you took some kind of an Excel course and it was super, super boring online. We need to have a modern digital training offering. And I would say that from we started doing that in 2022. And what we did was that, okay, we need to invest, we need to employ people who actually know something about this. We we had to have people who know how the digital training journey looks like. We needed to have uh digital designers who would come in and design what would the training look like. We needed to collaborate with the regulators because they needed to understand that now we are taking the training from the classroom, we are putting it online, and you know, how can you actually make sure that the students learn or the learners learn what they're supposed to learn? And I would say that we've been working with that since 2022 and up until now. In next month, in November, we are launching the first uh ATSEP trainings on a totally native AI-driven learning experience platform, which is super cool. So we have all our training materials is in English, but if you as a learner or when you as a learner, you go in and and and enter this platform, then you can use AI, you have a tutor next to you, you have a controlled AI environment, because we need to have that to live up to the regulation. And the learners can simply engage with the whole system there asking the system, can you explain this to me as if I was twelve years old? Can you give me some more examples on this, or can you give me more scenarios, or can you explain this in the Danish language, or in the Thai language, or whatever language you want? And this is something completely new, and I have not seen it anywhere in the world before. So we are super excited and proud to be able to live deliver this to the market.
SPEAKER_00That actually sounds like not just the um the bingo word like digitalization, everybody pretends to be digital nowadays. So thank you for giving us this concrete example. Maybe giving the listen listeners a little bit of more insight on how edcoeducation now works in EPN. So I'm old, I was I had to sit in a classroom and later on I was in the sim and I was always on site. How has this changed over, I guess, now the last uh five years or so? How does it look now? Can they do it from home? What can they do from home? Give us a bit of an idea.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, this is something that is very, very close to my heart, and I think that when we look at how we want to change air traffic control the training going forward, there are several elements that need to be in place. First of all, the regulation, because that is the basis, both the IKU regulation and also the European regulation. And I'm happy to say that we actually have regulations in force that enable us to work quite freely. And when we move into the competency-based training and assessment part, which EPN has been working with for the last five years, then we are moving away from the idea of every student needs to have 50 hours on the simulator and then they are done, and then they need to be able to pass the test or live up to the uh qualifications that are needed in a certain course. So it opened the regulation itself already today opens up for a flexibility, meaning that we can address the individual students much, much better than we have been able to do before. Then, if we look at the students coming into the industry right now, we EPN has done a rather large uh study since we have so many young students. We have done lots of interviews with students, different students from different countries. We have done interviews with customers, we have done interviews with all the instructors who are dealing with the uh with the students, and we have got a really, really good insight in what are the students, how how is their reality today? Because the students they come from a different background as you and I did, like 20, 30, 40 years ago when we entered the industry. And they are used to pick up learning so many different more many more places than in a classroom, sitting on the chair listening to the teacher. They pick up learning from so many different places, also in the digital environment. One of the things we also that the students also told us, they said that it's a huge pressure. We feel we are being assessed all the time by having instructors on our back all the time. So that was also something that we understood that okay, we need to we need to find a way to allow these students a little bit more breathing space when they are training something new. And you know, so I'm just explaining all this to give you an insight in how we think. So, what we are doing now is that we have a strategy called rethinking eCotraining. And underneath this strategy, we are working on a three parallel stream where we have one stream that we call concept development, where we are looking into how we can remodel the different modules. that we are that we are delivering. Then we have another stream with our uh NOSIN, that's the name of our simulator. How do we develop that? What kind of tools, what kind of data do we need to get out of our simulators when the students are performing on the simulators? And then we have we are working in general to become more data driven at EPN so that we can have objective grounds for the students, for the instructors and for the assessors. So we want to move away from the idea of an instructor saying like well I have a feeling that this student might not be able to do this and this if something and something happens. Because just having a feeling is not good enough. We need to have much more objective ground to base our decisions upon. So I think with all this that we're working on now and that we will be able to to uh to have some of it we have already some of it we will get during this coming year we will be able to become much more objective and we will be able to give both students, instructors and assessor much, much better tools. And it's really not about replacing the human because you cannot replace the humans it's not about that. But you can give the humans much better possibilities to make decisions based on objective grounds.
SPEAKER_00Which is basically the idea of CBTA and we mentioned it already quite a few times now just a little bit of background for non-European listeners CBTA is technically not something new. It has been in ICAO for a while but as everybody knows ICAO can say a lot of things and the countries normally don't follow as quickly as they should sometimes let's uh phrase it like that. In Europe the situation is a little bit different. We've got the European regulation agency EASA and they publish regulation in forms of quite often even laws which have to be followed. That's why we've got implementation deadlines and one of the regulations they've published is a firm implementation of CBTA in at co-training. Are you already fully prepared for the CBTA regulation to be enforced?
SPEAKER_01At EPN we have we have been working with CBTA in our courses for the last five years. So we are already we are good and and that's very nice but what we would like is of course also to support our partners and customers to become compliant because it's um I think it's something that can work super nice and super good as soon when it is implemented. But it is like it is a mindset shift for everybody being involved to start working in this different way. We're talking about you know that we have observable behaviors and that's what we are looking at when we deem if a if a learner or an EFCO can keep his or her competence. So so it is a mindset shift and it is not something that you do overnight. My recommendations to the uh operational people in the ANSPs would be that you need to start now to be to be ready by 29 you definitely need to start now look into what have you got and then discuss with your local regulator that what kind of outcome do you want to have before 2029 so you are ready and compliant.
SPEAKER_00Yeah I definitely agree it is really quite different than before you look at as you said more of gray zone I've I've got the feeling or I I think I my trainee does this or that not not that well. But now you have got right really a list of as you said behaviors that you can actually put check marks behind. And it all comes down to the quality of the behaviors that are on the list. For the initial training IASA has put everything in writing already but for later training it is down to the unit.
SPEAKER_01It has to define all that those criteria and I definitely agree the better the support is for example from uh entry point north the better the the training will be and you mentioned already the future a little Bangkok Thailand tell me Annekatine is it just Thailand or are you operating uh somewhere else as well no yeah I'm happy to say that that we are quite active in the uh Asia region we are doing business for the customers both in in uh in Thailand of course but also in the neighboring countries in Singapore in Vietnam in Indonesia and you know the idea to establish an academy in Bangkok came because you know it's quite costly. The airline fares from from Asia to Europe is really really costly and for our partners out in that region to send quite a lot of students to Europe is not a sustainable solution. They could send a few people you know people on a higher level in their um ANSPs they could send them to training but not when we're talking about the broader workforce we have been delivering or we are delivering quite a lot of digital services especially ACEP services in Asia and that's of course that doesn't come with any travel cost so that's that's easy and we handle that from our headquarters in Sweden. So that's a different story but being able to put a foot on the ground in Asia we thought was a really big step because it's the first site that we establish outside Europe and we are super excited to do so. And we we start a little bit small we have rented facilities in a technical university very close to Erutai. We have our first employees out there already now this week we have had staff and members and colleagues here from EPN being on ground in Bangkok setting up simulators preparing for for the audit that are happening actually yesterday and today. So with everything that we do we start a bit small and then we want to see how does it evolve how much can we do out there and we hope of course that we will be successful.
SPEAKER_00We are prepared to do the work to be so I hope so too we need all the good edcodes we can get everywhere around the world they are in high demand everywhere and we need good education for that we went through the kind of official history of EPN up to now and a little bit of the future but you personally Anne Katrine what was the most fun part in the last 20 years I think there have been so many moments that I have enjoyed it has been a huge challenge for me and I love a challenge but I come back to working with the uh different people that we are working in within EPN group I would say that that gives me the most joy.
SPEAKER_01I I think that is so stimulating you know seeing these different perspectives coming from different backgrounds different views of the world and and and that is just that's my greatest joy during these 20 years. It's really hard to answer the question about what is the most fun because I would say as a general it really is this with the people but then I also think that working with the digitalization right now is also so so interesting and how can we do it in a good way so that people don't feel that well AI is just coming and sweeping everybody off their feet and you know leaving no humans in the loop and so on which is not the case. And and that's a super interesting challenge because many people are afraid of that. So you know how do we go around that? How do we uh get people on board that actually they can they can do their job in a much better and more confident way than they are doing it today.
SPEAKER_00So it was it would be much more um satisfying for them when they have for instance objective means to make their decisions upon yeah I remember distinctly then when I was in training and I had all the theoretical classes I could answer all the questions but later on when I was in the simulator I finally understood what I had learned before. Yeah. And I thought that was a huge waste of potential and waste of time to have this huge disconnect and I I would have loved a kind of an AI which I could ask okay explain it like I'm five what why am I learning this? What do you mean? And so it it it it actually sounds like a good idea.
SPEAKER_01And and and and also you're able to ask these questions without having an instructor thinking is she dumb or what? So you know it it's nice that you can do a little bit on your own. And and that's I didn't explain that but in the simulator since we're now using autopiloting which is AI-based then we can allow the students so much more time in the simulator in the ECO positions and they can train on their own. You know for some students they I would say old students they they maybe like to experiment a little bit could I what happens if I turn him a little bit before or what happened if I turn him really really sharp a little bit later. Maybe they know it's not gonna go well but they just want to see how it looks and doing that without having an instructor sitting judging why did you do that? You should have known that this is not going to work that's a huge thing for the students and it it built confidence for them. And I just think that building confidence in the students is so important because later on they come out to the unit and the more you know the more they believe in themselves the better position they have joining the units.
SPEAKER_00Are the students able to use the simulator at any time since it's now doesn't need any pilots on the other side?
SPEAKER_01Yes yes we allow our students we say to the students you're welcome to come in earlier in the morning you're also welcome to stay later in the evening and and you can train and and they do so they kind of agree very often they go together four or five together and say shouldn't we stay we want to train this or and they can help each other also which is also important because in the study we made with the students we asked them also so where who do you go to to s to seek support and we maybe thought okay they might ask the instructors they might might ask the co-supervisor they might ask the psychologist that we have around but they said no I go to my peers I go to the other students because that's such a safe environment for them and and enabling them to train together a little bit and at the same time allowing the assessors and the instructors you know they can pull out everything afterwards if they want and the students can as well to see how did that look. So it's not like it's not like it's a free playground they can but it's in a very controlled environment still and and and I think just the students get the same amount of instructor interaction but on top of that they are able to spend more time and train more free.
SPEAKER_00So I I think it's a win-win that's really good because just a few trainees I had they really needed that that kind of space I mean I'm working in a knife system obviously but still just giving the trainee the idea well do whatever you like. Yeah try it out I will step in in time if it doesn't work don't worry just go ahead with your plan go ahead just give them a boost and then uh then make a better plan next time. Exactly exactly yeah so that's good thank you so much Anne Katrine um we will talk again maybe in five years at the 25th anniversary maybe you will talk with somebody else then somebody else maybe thank you you're very welcome it was a pleasure thank you and if anyone wants to know more you can visit their website entrypointnorth.com and find out more